Justice Sheilah Martin, writing for the unanimous decision of the seven justices (Chief Justice Richard Wagner, and Justices Andromache Karakatsanis, Suzanne Côté, Malcolm Rowe, Nicholas Kasirer and Mahmud Jamal) who heard the case, supported the trial judge’s decision, and expanded upon it, offering additional guidance regarding situations where police are required to disclose information about misconduct. In her decision, Justice Martin stressed that it is the Crown’s duty to decide what is relevant police conduct and what isn’t and therefore what needs to be disclosed to the accused. She also reiterated that landmark cases dealing with this issue, including Stinchcombe, R. v. O’Connor, [1995] 4 S.C.R. 411, and R. v. McNeil, are settled law. Justice Martin also detailed 10 principles to consider when contemplating misconduct disclosures.