In Xilinx Inc. v. Papst Licensing GmbH & Co. KG, Appeal No. 2015-1919 (Fed. Cir. Feb. 15, 2017), the Federal Circuit applied the usual test for in personam jurisdiction, in an apparently new way, to reverse dismissal of a declaratory judgment suit against an alien patent owner seeking to avoid the alleged infringer’s home forum. More specifically, a panel consisting of Chief Judge Prost and Circuit Judges Newman and Dyk held that the Northern District of California had specific personal jurisdiction over a German patent owner, Papst Licensing GmbH & Co. KG, that, as a nonpracticing entity and in accordance with its usual practice, mailed notice to the alleged infringer, Xilinx, Inc., that it was infringing and should consider taking a license. After Papst mailed that notice, Papst representatives traveled to California and met with Xilinx representatives to discuss Papst’s allegations and potential licensing. When no agreement was reached, Xilinx filed a declaratory judgment suit in the Northern District seeking a declaration of invalidity and noninfringement. Papst moved to dismiss for lack of in personam jurisdiction or to transfer to the District of Delaware, where Papst had filed an infringement suit against Xilinx.
More Posts
Licensees Stymied by Sovereign Immunity Both in Federal Court and at PTAB
Federal Circuit Provides Guidance on Divided Infringement, Inducement of Infringement, and Indefiniteness
Biotech Patent Dispute Between Academics That Is Far From Academic
Federal Circuit Panel Splits in Important Decision Regarding Its Jurisdiction over Institution of IPRs
A Split Panel of the Federal Circuit Debates the Standards for Definiteness
Federal Circuit Holds PTAB Unreasonable in Denying Motion to Amend
PTO Provides Additional Guidance on Patent Eligibility of Life-Sciences Method Claims
Federal Circuit Provides Additional Guidance in Reversing Holding of Patent-Ineligibility of Biotech Invention
Court Decides that ANDA Approved Before Patent Issued Cannot Infringe 35 U.S.C. § 271(e)(2)(A)
Subscribe: Subscribe via RSS
Blogs
Firm/Org